Hr team I have a request, plz keep the camera on one of the sheikhs when he is leading so that I get an idea how they pray n I can also correct my prayers by watching them how they pray. Bcoz according to the hadiths of the beloved Prophet ( saw) I have found that the Saudi way of praying is most accurate.
Thats not necessarily true. the great scholars of the past have differed on many issues of salah, and even the haramain imams they don't all pray the same.
These issues are more complex than merely saying that the saudi way of praying is most accurate. Hadith scholars have disagreed on the authenticity of many ahadeeth regarding prayer. For example, where to put the hands in salah while standing. Ibn al Munzir (d318ah) says there are no authentic narrations with regards to this. Imaam tirmizi mentions that some sahaba and tabieen are of the view that it should be above the navel and others below, and all were acceptable according to them. That's why you may see some imams have their hands lower than others e.g Shaykh Saalih al Humaid and Kalbani. Even now there are many saudi scholars who are of this view. You don't have to pray like a saudi to be considered 'salafi', as technically all the 4 imams base their views upon actions of the salaf.
@ Anonymous 5 but there r some aspects that can't be ignored e.g. Raising ur hands till ears before going to ruku etc. coz some hadiths r found which order this. All the four imams said that if any of our sayings go against the hadiths n Quranic commandments then throw it on the wall. Conclusion if we have a authentic Hadith then the sayings of the highly respected imams don't carry any weight.
8 comments:
Hr team I have a request, plz keep the camera on one of the sheikhs when he is leading so that I get an idea how they pray n I can also correct my prayers by watching them how they pray. Bcoz according to the hadiths of the beloved Prophet ( saw) I have found that the Saudi way of praying is most accurate.
We only record the salaah from the TV/internet, we have no control over the cameras. :)
hrstaff plz plz plz post a list of the muazins of makkah and madina with a recordin of they azaan
jazakallah may allah reward you abundantly
Thats not necessarily true. the great scholars of the past have differed on many issues of salah, and even the haramain imams they don't all pray the same.
These issues are more complex than merely saying that the saudi way of praying is most accurate. Hadith scholars have disagreed on the authenticity of many ahadeeth regarding prayer. For example, where to put the hands in salah while standing. Ibn al Munzir (d318ah) says there are no authentic narrations with regards to this. Imaam tirmizi mentions that some sahaba and tabieen are of the view that it should be above the navel and others below, and all were acceptable according to them. That's why you may see some imams have their hands lower than others e.g Shaykh Saalih al Humaid and Kalbani. Even now there are many saudi scholars who are of this view. You don't have to pray like a saudi to be considered 'salafi', as technically all the 4 imams base their views upon actions of the salaf.
Link for Makkah Mu'adhins:
http://haramainrecordings.blogspot.co.uk/search?q=sheikh+ali+shakir
The ones that are missing are:
Shaykh Ali Mullah
Shaykh Asim Ali Khan
Shaykh Ahmed Khoja
Shaykh Ali Ahmed Nuhas
NOTE: Shaykh Abdulaziz Raees has passed away
Shaykh Muhammad Muadhin very rarely gives the Adhan
Yes brother they follow the salaf al salih
@ Anonymous 5 but there r some aspects that can't be ignored e.g. Raising ur hands till ears before going to ruku etc. coz some hadiths r found which order this. All the four imams said that if any of our sayings go against the hadiths n Quranic commandments then throw it on the wall. Conclusion if we have a authentic Hadith then the sayings of the highly respected imams don't carry any weight.
Post a Comment