I dont think the respected Shaykh hafizahullahu ta'ala would leave salaah on the basis of a cough. Most likely the Shaykh's wudhu broke, and the fact that he broke his salaah straight away is a sign of his immense taqwa. And Allah knows best.
May ALLAH bless him and keep him healthy all the time
at 1:19, he seems to be looking at his hand. Maybe something happen? But for sure there seems to be a problem with his throat. This is just not his usual voice/tone.
also, can someone explain what happen? what he say? and under what circumstance can an Imam do that? Sorry i Don't know
This also shows, How the Sheikhs are well educated and know all the rules about leading namaz since he knew what to do in that situation. May ALLAH increase their and our knowledge about Islam, Ameen
Its Amazing How We Rarely See The Imams Breaking Salaat For Some Reason Or Doing Sajdah Sahw In The Harams. Imagine The Amount Of Concentration That Is Needed. If The Mistakes In Salat Were Not Made In The Time Of The Prophet SAW Would We Have Even Known What To Do For Example When To Make Sajdah Sahw E.T.C And What Would Have Been Our Reaction If We Hadn't Been Taught That. The Life Of The Prophet SAW Teaches Us Each And Everything.
Brothers And Sisters, I think there was something on the Respected Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy Bisht... if you look carefully you can see him trying to discover what is on the sleeve on the bisht. the reason for the change of tune was because he had to rush again to lead the congregation in Salaat. Which ever mosque you'd be in and if you were the imam and you made an error, you automatically start panicking and you can be heard breathing heavily. Its natural. The Respected Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy has the responsibility in leading thousands in congregation Although Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy Is Much Older Than The Other Imams. Whilst The Camera Is Turned Away, You can also hear Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy telling those behind or the responsible person behind what the problem was.They can't just put any substitute imam to lead the congregation. however in Makkah, Zuhr Salaat is lead by someother Shaykh Who Is Not The Main Imam. May Allah Grant Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy Barakah In His Age.
maybe sheikh was bleeding on his hand or broke his wuduh, whatever the case its very good he handled the situation very well rather then carrying on the salah, these things happen we are only human, sallam!
in islam it is not ok to leave the salah for a sore through or so on you can only leave for a depiret case like a deth or life case >>ext as for taharah he must leave and thaat is what i think (we shouled allways think the best)wallah a,alam
Brothers and sisters we dont need to discuss what happend. What happend, happend. In respect of sheikh, he has so much knowledge, hes been teaching and learning the knowledge of deen all his life, there is no doubt he knows the masaails of salah extremely well and he did what he knows was right. Allah knows best but maybe he is from amongst those who are the most knowledgable in our present age. By saying what i said i dont mean to criticize anyone whose commented, thoughts came to my mind aswel when i saw this video, but i reminded myself who sheikh is. Allah knows best what happend, if sheikh made a mistake or not, but we are not people to judge, everyone makes mistakes. Allah reward Sheikh Huthaify in this world and the hereafter.
Brothers And Sisters In Islam.... Sheikh Hudhayfee Has Much Knowledge Thank You And I. We Should Leave This Issue And Ask Our Local Ulama Of The Masala. Different Madhabs Different Rules
I think he either broke his wudu, or had to use the bathroom or was bleeding maybe. I seriously doubt he being such a learned person break his salah for a bad throat. And there is a differce of opinion among scholors whether a person should say salam to break the salah or just break it, and allah knows best!
The proper method if you break your Wudhu is to put your left hand over your mouth and put your hand on another person capable of leading the salaat and bring him to the musalah to lead the Salaat. Or you could just say Salaam, make your wudhu, and return and restart the Salaat. I'm a bit confused as to what the Sheikh did, he didn't say Salaam or anything.
First, the Shaykh is human so maybe he did break Wudhu or forget he had wudhu. Secondly, I'm sure these Shuyookh have knowledge and are aware of the correct procedure should such circumstances occur. May Allah give him khair and give us the ability to respect the people of knowledge
After some of the comments from the brothers and sisters above, why do some people insist on commenting regarding things which will never be clarified, discussing "maybes" is an endless journey. Theres no need to give opinions on fiqh either, as the fiqh of different imams differ, for one masla there are many different opinions, not to mention the layman can get confused by hearing many things. I dont mean to argue but whats happend let it pass, the past cant be changed. We owe sheikh soo much respect, and by quoting masaails on this particular post, without specifically directing them at anyone who has asked (if someone has), its implying that sheikh never considered the masla, or sheikh doesnt know. My brothers and sisters approach this matter with taqwa and tawadhu, i only say this because it hurts that people would talk about our ulama without the consideration of the implications of their comments, i ask allah to forgive me, i am your brother and i too make mistakes.
Come on brothers, Shaykh has been an imam of the haramain for the past 30+ years. Im sure he is well aware of the masaail regarding this situation, and we are foolish to even suggest he did something wrong. Thousands of people are praying behind him, whose salah are dependent on him. Please stop speculating as to why he did this, and whether he was correct in the manner he did it.
I must say its only becoz of the combination of Shiekh Hudaify and Haramain recordings that we learnt a way to overcome such situations.Thanks to Shiekh and dear haramain staff you are the best
He's a great imam filled with piety, and EXTREMELY lucky to be leading salah in front of the Prophet SAW.
Surely the Shaykh is chosen by Allah and his Prophet to be among the righteous ones.
And plus he is very learned and knowledgable, dont question his actions, please. He knows what he's doing.
I know the curiosity is just eating some of us and everyone would LOVE to know the reason as to why he did that, so we in return could learn from him under which type of circumstances Salah can be broken in, but please try to control your inner feelings/curiosity/comments ETC.. ETC.. ETC..
theres nothing wrong with his mislah/bisht. If there was something wrong, it wouldv'e been enough to take it off, and wouldn't need to leave. It mustv've been that he broke his wudu. In the hanbali madhab, if the imams salah breaks then the followers break as well. I don't know what the hanbali madhab says in terms of istikhlaaf ( imam leaving another to lead) though
31 comments:
someone explain, rnt u supposed to say salaam or somehting
I dont think the respected Shaykh hafizahullahu ta'ala would leave salaah on the basis of a cough. Most likely the Shaykh's wudhu broke, and the fact that he broke his salaah straight away is a sign of his immense taqwa. And Allah knows best.
May allah(s.w.t) give him shifaa...Aameen
may allah forgive him
He looked disturbed
Maybe he broke his wudhu or something. I doubt he would break his salaat for a bad throat.
May ALLAH bless him and keep him healthy all the time
at 1:19, he seems to be looking at his hand. Maybe something happen? But for sure there seems to be a problem with his throat. This is just not his usual voice/tone.
also, can someone explain what happen? what he say? and under what circumstance can an Imam do that? Sorry i Don't know
This also shows, How the Sheikhs are well educated and know all the rules about leading namaz since he knew what to do in that situation. May ALLAH increase their and our knowledge about Islam, Ameen
Its Amazing How We Rarely See The Imams Breaking Salaat For Some Reason Or Doing Sajdah Sahw In The Harams.
Imagine The Amount Of Concentration That Is Needed. If The Mistakes In Salat Were Not Made In The Time Of The Prophet SAW Would We Have Even Known What To Do For Example When To Make Sajdah Sahw E.T.C And What Would Have Been Our Reaction If We Hadn't Been Taught That. The Life Of The Prophet SAW Teaches Us Each And Everything.
Brothers And Sisters, I think there was something on the Respected Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy Bisht... if you look carefully you can see him trying to discover what is on the sleeve on the bisht. the reason for the change of tune was because he had to rush again to lead the congregation in Salaat. Which ever mosque you'd be in and if you were the imam and you made an error, you automatically start panicking and you can be heard breathing heavily. Its natural. The Respected Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy has the responsibility in leading thousands in congregation Although Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy Is Much Older Than The Other Imams. Whilst The Camera Is Turned Away, You can also hear Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy telling those behind or the responsible person behind what the problem was.They can't just put any substitute imam to lead the congregation. however in Makkah, Zuhr Salaat is lead by someother Shaykh Who Is Not The Main Imam. May Allah Grant Sheikh Ali Abdur Rahmaan Al Hudhaifiyy Barakah In His Age.
It showed me that he's REALLY deserve to be an imam in masjidun nabawi mashallah
Interesting maybe he had no ablution or broke it. Allah knows best.
can any body explain me this through shriath e islam and hadees(hadeed) plzzzz
maybe sheikh was bleeding on his hand or broke his wuduh, whatever the case its very good he handled the situation very well rather then carrying on the salah, these things happen we are only human, sallam!
in islam it is not ok to leave the salah for a sore through or so on you can only leave for a depiret case like a deth or life case >>ext
as for taharah he must leave and thaat is what i think (we shouled allways think the best)wallah a,alam
Brothers and sisters we dont need to discuss what happend. What happend, happend. In respect of sheikh, he has so much knowledge, hes been teaching and learning the knowledge of deen all his life, there is no doubt he knows the masaails of salah extremely well and he did what he knows was right. Allah knows best but maybe he is from amongst those who are the most knowledgable in our present age. By saying what i said i dont mean to criticize anyone whose commented, thoughts came to my mind aswel when i saw this video, but i reminded myself who sheikh is. Allah knows best what happend, if sheikh made a mistake or not, but we are not people to judge, everyone makes mistakes. Allah reward Sheikh Huthaify in this world and the hereafter.
bad throat isnt that kinda stupid?
Brothers And Sisters In Islam.... Sheikh Hudhayfee Has Much Knowledge Thank You And I. We Should Leave This Issue And Ask Our Local Ulama Of The Masala. Different Madhabs Different Rules
hmm mmmm
Allah knows Best!
dont assume and falsly accuse the honourable Sheikh of Masjid al Nabawi
may Allah reward our esteemed imam al qari sheikh al hudaifi. ameen
I think he either broke his wudu, or had to use the bathroom or was bleeding maybe. I seriously doubt he being such a learned person break his salah for a bad throat. And there is a differce of opinion among scholors whether a person should say salam to break the salah or just break it, and allah knows best!
The proper method if you break your Wudhu is to put your left hand over your mouth and put your hand on another person capable of leading the salaat and bring him to the musalah to lead the Salaat. Or you could just say Salaam, make your wudhu, and return and restart the Salaat. I'm a bit confused as to what the Sheikh did, he didn't say Salaam or anything.
u all are ASSUMING that his whudhu broke!
pls dont talk from your hats!
First, the Shaykh is human so maybe he did break Wudhu or forget he had wudhu. Secondly, I'm sure these Shuyookh have knowledge and are aware of the correct procedure should such circumstances occur. May Allah give him khair and give us the ability to respect the people of knowledge
After some of the comments from the brothers and sisters above, why do some people insist on commenting regarding things which will never be clarified, discussing "maybes" is an endless journey. Theres no need to give opinions on fiqh either, as the fiqh of different imams differ, for one masla there are many different opinions, not to mention the layman can get confused by hearing many things. I dont mean to argue but whats happend let it pass, the past cant be changed. We owe sheikh soo much respect, and by quoting masaails on this particular post, without specifically directing them at anyone who has asked (if someone has), its implying that sheikh never considered the masla, or sheikh doesnt know. My brothers and sisters approach this matter with taqwa and tawadhu, i only say this because it hurts that people would talk about our ulama without the consideration of the implications of their comments, i ask allah to forgive me, i am your brother and i too make mistakes.
Come on brothers, Shaykh has been an imam of the haramain for the past 30+ years. Im sure he is well aware of the masaail regarding this situation, and we are foolish to even suggest he did something wrong. Thousands of people are praying behind him, whose salah are dependent on him. Please stop speculating as to why he did this, and whether he was correct in the manner he did it.
I must say its only becoz of the combination of Shiekh Hudaify and Haramain recordings that we learnt a way to overcome such situations.Thanks to Shiekh and dear haramain staff you are the best
Is it allowed to just leave the Salaat like that? I thought you had to say Salaam first.
Hope everythings okay with him.
He's a great imam filled with piety, and EXTREMELY lucky to be leading salah in front of the Prophet SAW.
Surely the Shaykh is chosen by Allah and his Prophet to be among the righteous ones.
And plus he is very learned and knowledgable, dont question his actions, please. He knows what he's doing.
I know the curiosity is just eating some of us and everyone would LOVE to know the reason as to why he did that, so we in return could learn from him under which type of circumstances Salah can be broken in, but please try to control your inner feelings/curiosity/comments ETC.. ETC.. ETC..
Dont take it personnally anybody :)
There was obviously something on his MishlaH; they way he looked at it then took it off.
theres nothing wrong with his mislah/bisht. If there was something wrong, it wouldv'e been enough to take it off, and wouldn't need to leave. It mustv've been that he broke his wudu. In the hanbali madhab, if the imams salah breaks then the followers break as well. I don't know what the hanbali madhab says in terms of istikhlaaf ( imam leaving another to lead) though
Ya allah give us the same thaqwa, as of our beloved shaikh!!!!
which imam does shaikh huthaify follow
Post a Comment