salam aleykum, i always visit this website to listen juhayni's recitation, and y have to say that this imitation is the best imitation that i've never heard before, mashaAllah may Allah protect you brother mehdi
As a daily listener of haramain recordings and Islam-fr which also has the haramain recordings. I have to honestly say. And by no means am I crticizing the reciter for he recites far better than me. Rather, a constructive critique of the comments. Its sounds absolutely nothing like Johany. Neither in terms of the speed, fluency, tone, pitch. He sounds nothing like him. For people to say he it is the best imitation they have heard. I have to be quite frank in saying that you need to listen to Johany a few hundred times and then maybe you will come to the conclusion that this reciter sounds nothing like Imam-al-Haram in Makkah Abdullah Al-Joahny. One final point. The website is called HARAMAIN RECORDINGS so I believe that means it should be for only for the recitation of the Haramain Imaams. If you want to put up an imitation go on YouTube.
I do not intend in any way and Allah knows my intention to offend anyone by this comment.
May Allah accept, reward and increase the reciter in his recitation and everyone who contributes to this website. Aameen
I JUST WANTED TO SAY TO THE LAST BROTHER WHO LET A COMMENT THAT THE ADMIN OF THIS WEBSITE CREATED A SECTION WHIWH NAMED "POST YOUR RECITATION" SO IT WAS ESPECIALLY CREATED FOR THE BROTHERS WHO WANTED TO POST THEIR RECITATION, PERSONNALY I DON'T THINK THAT IT'S A GOOD IDEA TO ADVICE TO A BROTHER TO POST HIS RECXITATION ON A MUSIC WEBSITE LIKE YOUTUBE BECAUSE THIS IS NOT A SONG BUT THE SAYS OF ALLAH THE CREATOR. AND I ALSO WANTED TO SAY THAT I KNOW THE BROTHER MEHDI AND I CAN SAY TO YOU THAT SHEIKH ABDULLAH AL JOHANY LISTENED TO HIS RECITATION AND HE SAID THAT IT WAS SO GOOD AND BEAUTIFUL. AND TO FINISH I JUST HAVE AN ADVICE FOR YOU: THE MUSLIM ONE HAVE TO ENCOURAGE HIS BROTHER AND NOT TO SPEAK ILL BECAUSE WHAT YOU SAID BRO WAS NOT A USEFULL CRITICIZE. SORRY IT IS MY POINT OF VIEW.
PS: I'M SORRY FOR MY ENGLISH, IM not from england but from france so this is not my natural language
6 comments:
salam aleykum,
i always visit this website to listen juhayni's recitation, and y have to say that this imitation is the best imitation that i've never heard before, mashaAllah
may Allah protect you brother mehdi
Assalamu Alaykum
Mashallah a very good recitation bro! Keep it up! :)
Ameen to the dua ^
well tis beautiful mashallah as a dayly viewer like me would say mashallah
aselemu 'aleykum wa rahmatou allahi
masha Allah, this is a beautifull imitation!
could you please send more files of juhany's imitation.
may allah bless you amine
Assalaamualaikum,
As a daily listener of haramain recordings and Islam-fr which also has the haramain recordings. I have to honestly say. And by no means am I crticizing the reciter for he recites far better than me. Rather, a constructive critique of the comments. Its sounds absolutely nothing like Johany. Neither in terms of the speed, fluency, tone, pitch. He sounds nothing like him. For people to say he it is the best imitation they have heard. I have to be quite frank in saying that you need to listen to Johany a few hundred times and then maybe you will come to the conclusion that this reciter sounds nothing like Imam-al-Haram in Makkah Abdullah Al-Joahny. One final point. The website is called HARAMAIN RECORDINGS so I believe that means it should be for only for the recitation of the Haramain Imaams. If you want to put up an imitation go on YouTube.
I do not intend in any way and Allah knows my intention to offend anyone by this comment.
May Allah accept, reward and increase the reciter in his recitation and everyone who contributes to this website. Aameen
Wassalaam
Asalamu aleykum wa rahamtou LLAH
I JUST WANTED TO SAY TO THE LAST BROTHER WHO LET A
COMMENT THAT THE ADMIN OF THIS WEBSITE CREATED A SECTION WHIWH NAMED "POST YOUR RECITATION" SO IT WAS ESPECIALLY CREATED FOR THE BROTHERS WHO WANTED TO POST THEIR RECITATION, PERSONNALY I DON'T THINK THAT IT'S A GOOD IDEA TO ADVICE TO A BROTHER TO POST HIS RECXITATION ON A MUSIC WEBSITE LIKE YOUTUBE BECAUSE THIS IS NOT A SONG BUT THE SAYS OF ALLAH THE CREATOR.
AND I ALSO WANTED TO SAY THAT I KNOW THE BROTHER MEHDI AND I CAN SAY TO YOU THAT SHEIKH ABDULLAH AL JOHANY LISTENED TO HIS RECITATION AND HE SAID THAT IT WAS SO GOOD AND BEAUTIFUL. AND TO FINISH I JUST HAVE AN ADVICE FOR YOU: THE MUSLIM ONE HAVE TO ENCOURAGE HIS BROTHER AND NOT TO SPEAK ILL BECAUSE WHAT YOU SAID BRO WAS NOT A USEFULL CRITICIZE. SORRY IT IS MY POINT OF VIEW.
PS: I'M SORRY FOR MY ENGLISH, IM not from england but from france so this is not my natural language
Post a Comment